Skip to main content

Milk: an Indian success story

There are many ideas in Verghese Kurien’s autobiography I Too Had a Dream that will stir the minds of independent retailers. His is the story of how the little guy wins. Of how to work with markets to win success. Of the importance of marketing. And how to leverage advantage from your connections.

Dr Kurien's achievements are remarkable. How he developed the Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation in a sleepy rural town 350 miles north of Mumbai, India has lessons for independent operators in the UK today.

The town Anand started supplying milk to Mumbai in the 1940s after a milk scare. An enterprising businessman Pestonjee Edulji, who owned the Polson butter factory in Anand, persuaded the British to give him the rights to supply milk to the city.

Armed with the sole distribution rights, Pestonjee first created big demand for Anand milk and second exploited the farmers who produced it. The British were happy with the better milk supplies and Pestonjee became very wealthy.

However Anand is in Gujarat, the home state of Mohandas Gandhi. Gandhi's right hand man Sardar Patel encouraged the farmers to work together to get a fair deal. By coincidence the Indian government sent the young Dr Kurien to work with the co-operative and he provided the leadership to make them successful.

In 1946 the co-operative asked the commissioner of the Bombay milk scheme to accept milk direct from them. The commissioner said no. The farmers went on strike and poured all their milk away. For two weeks, Polson could get no milk and its agreement with the Bombay milk commissioner collapsed. Over the next 18 years, the co-operative competed with Polson and won.

“We had one clear advantage in that unlike private companies impatient to make profits we were very patient,” says Dr Kurien.

He organised all the local milk co-operatives together and created a marketing organisation so they could sell effectively and he created a brand Amul that today is the market leader in India.

“One of the earliest lessons I had learnt was that Amul existed because barely a few hundred kilometres away Bombay existed. There could be production here only because a market was there.” While the Bombay milk scheme had exploited the farmers, it had also created the market opportunity for them.

When they started selling butter under the Amul name they found it hard to reach the market as it was controlled by Anchor butter from New Zealand and Polson’s products. So Dr Kurien lobbied the Indian government to cut the import of butter, which it did. This created an opening for Amul butter to achieve distribution.

Unlike private suppliers, who watered down products, Amul always delivered quality. Its butter was purer than the competition but users were accustomed to the Polson taste. So Amul had to get the colour and taste and salt levels correct. Giving the “customer quality products” was the value that meant when its advertising grabbed attention, consumers liked what they bought.

After this success the Indian government, which was of a socialist bent, asked Dr Kurien to introduce the co-operative model to other parts of India. What he found was the vested interests in other Indian states made it hard to reproduce his successful business model.

Perhaps his greatest success was leading the National Dairy Development Board. He came up with a plan to use surplus food from Europe to rebalance the milk market in India so that local suppliers could compete with multinationals and to increase milk production. From the 1970s to the 1990s India moved from a position where it was an importer of milk to becoming the largest milk producer in the world. In 30 years the NDDB plan doubled the milk available per person and made dairy farming successful.

Dr Kurien helped the small farmer win because he encouraged them to:
·        Equip themselves with the latest technology
·        Set themselves world class standards
·        Put in place systems that ensured they consistently achieved high standards.

His life story is inspiring and worth a place on your business book shelf.
For more see www.betterretailing.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Digital disruption in the UK wholesale space

“Twenty years ago I was driving boxes to the post office in my Chevy Blazer and dreaming of a forklift,” says Jeff Bezos in his most recent letter to shareholders. A blink later and he points out that the company has grown from 30,000 employees in 2010 to 230,000 now. But his ambition is the same. “We want to be a large company that’s also an invention machine. We want to combine the extraordinary customer-serving capabilities that are enabled by size with the speed of movement, nimbleness and risk-acceptance mentality that is normally associated with entrepreneurial start-ups.” Amazon is great at disruption because of its customers focus and the fact that the internet means it needs none (or very few) people between its warehouses and the shopper. The threat of Prime, its membership service, is the biggest challenge facing the UK retail market and the wholesale market by extension. It is both a direct threat and an indirect threat in that is inspiring countless numbers of othe...

Traffic lights: a fuss about nothing

I am sure that FT columnist Michael Skapinker has written about traffic lights food labelling before and his latest article is provocatively called: The food companies that make people fat. He criticises Coca-Cola and Unilever for sticking with guideline daily amounts (GDAs) when traffic lights work much better. Former Walmart Europe public affairs head Bernard Hughes wrote in to support Skapinker. He said: "There isn't ever a perfect information system flowing with beautiful logic. But traffic lights give powerful direction to the busy consumer." But in this age of smart phones surely this debate over the labelling on the packaging is easily overcome. The government can simply issue an app that when held over a bar code provides shoppers with a traffic light system. The supermarkets could do this on their websites. Surely the whole point about the future is that the internet and limitless data storage means that the shopper is being empowered with the informatio...

Sunday trading consultation: fair or fixed? You decide.

My local council, South Oxfordshire, asked me to complete a survey on Sunday trading as a local resident. The deadline is next week. The first question was about the current arrangements and what I thought. There were five options: large shops shouldn’t open six hours is already too long current restrictions are about right large shops should be allowed open for longer no restrictions. My answer was the current restrictions are about right. The next question was about what would happen if the council allowed large stores to open for longer. The menu included 10 options and a space for other. The options were that it would: encourage me to shop more in my local town give me more flexibility impact on my religious or cultural beliefs have a positive impact on my business have a negative impact on my business increase footfall to my business reduce footfall to my business provide more employment opportunities open to me in the local area mean that I need to...