Skip to main content

Are you high fidelity or high convenience?

If you earn your living in the retail industry the possibility that the business that you’re in will still exist in two, five and 10 years is very slim, says Doug Stephens, US retail expert in the first line of his new book The Retail Revival.

“Sorry for the buzzkill,” he adds. “But it’s true.”

Fizzing with ideas, this book is the start of a journey. Stephens tackles all of the issues that you’ve heard about, such as big data and showrooming and puts them into context.

In a chapter entitled The Destination is You he discusses how mobile phones open up the possibility that big brands will find shoppers wherever they go. In the future as a customer is about to enter your shop, big brands could push promotions towards them and your competitors, like Tesco Express, could try and poach their business with a home delivery offer.

Sam Walton’s reputation as a genius of retail comes under close scrutiny from Stephens. He argues that demographic changes lay behind the success of Walmart. The US baby boom that kicked in in the 1960s and lasted for 20 years meant there were lots of children growing up in households with plenty of money.

“Quality would take a back seat to availability and abundance would triumph over substance,” Stephen argues.

“When I began my career as a retail marketer in the early 1990s pricing just about any product or service was a cinch as long as you followed one simple formula. The ‘good, better, best’ pricing convention that most retail marketers had used for the last 60 years was a surefire model.”

Another advantage was that shoppers in this period wanted to buy what everyone else was buying. Big brands could cheaply reach 80 per cent of the population with just three TV ads and average stuff for average people worked.

But the internet has changed all that, Stephens argues. The model is broken and using the Walmart toolkit will not work anymore. Today’s retailers have to choose one of two models:
  • High fidelity
  • High convenience.
Reading about his views of these two places on the map, you can start to understand how a local shop could do well next door to a Tesco Express if it gets high fidelity correct. What is high fidelity? There is no one answer to that but it is about how you present your offer to your world.

A good example is Apple’s approach to retail. They worried about the detail. The customer experience “was so precisely engineered that there were even certain things that employees were not permitted to say while helping customers. For example the word unfortunately, as in ‘unfortunately we don’t have that item in stock.’ Instead staff were instructed to use the words as it turns out, as in ‘as it turns out we don’t have that item in stock.’ Which Apple viewed as a less negative way of communicating the same out-of-stock situation. From there staff were instructed to offer a solution aimed at making the customer happy despite the situation.”

Stephens book is aimed at retail executives and big brand marketers. But local shopkeepers will find it helps explain the world you live in, helps explain why your suppliers do certain things and most importantly it will set your mind thinking how to do a better job for your customers.


Bricks and mortar retailing is not dead. In fact, Stephens may even be optimistic about your chances if you read the small print. “The future will be better tomorrow,” he concludes, quoting from Dan Quayle.
For more, go to www.betterretailing.com.

Comments